Arguability

Arguability refers to the degree to which a statement, claim, or proposition can be supported with evidence, reason, and logical argumentation. It encompasses the potential for being debated, contested, or justified through rational discourse. A highly arguable statement is one that is open to multiple interpretations, viewpoints, and supporting evidence, making it a subject of active discussion and analysis. Conversely, a statement with low arguability is one that is generally accepted, lacks significant supporting evidence, or fails to generate meaningful disagreement.

Arguability meaning with examples

• The scientist examined the arguability of the proposed hypothesis, scrutinizing its underlying assumptions and the availability of empirical data to support it. He knew a strong hypothesis has a high degree of arguability, sparking vigorous debate and further research, thus advancing our understanding of the subject matter, which would not happen with a non-arguable statement.
• During the political debate, the candidates assessed the arguability of their opposing viewpoints. Understanding where their positions could be challenged and which points of contention could be justified allowed them to effectively counter-argue, providing their audience with a clear understanding of the evidence behind their claims, and showing the benefits of an arguable position.
• The judge evaluated the arguability of the lawyer's arguments, considering the relevance and weight of the presented evidence. A high degree of arguability on a defendant's part, would lead to a thorough cross-examination of witnesses and scrutiny of legal precedents, as well as the potential for the claim to hold ground, versus one without the ability to be debated, or without evidence.
• Before publishing the essay, the editor reviewed the arguability of the author's claims, ensuring that each assertion was supported by verifiable facts and logical reasoning. Knowing how arguability would stand, and what would be open for discussion, would allow the essay to be more thought-provoking and provide clear positions to make it a piece worth reading for its open nature.