Non-refereed

Describing a publication, academic work, or scholarly material that has not undergone peer review or assessment by experts in the relevant field. This type of content is often published in venues without a formal process for evaluating the quality, accuracy, or originality of the work. non-refereed materials can include books, newsletters, conference proceedings, articles in non-peer-reviewed journals, blogs, and websites. They are typically less rigorous than refereed publications, and the information presented should be evaluated critically by the reader. The absence of peer review can impact the credibility and reliability of the information.

Non-refereed meaning with examples

• The professor cautioned students to be wary of using online encyclopedia entries as primary sources, citing their non-refereed nature. Unlike peer-reviewed journal articles, these sources often lack rigorous fact-checking, potentially leading to inaccuracies. He urged them to use sources from verified and scholarly locations, prioritizing accuracy and reliability in their research.
• The researcher decided to publish her initial findings in a non-refereed conference proceeding to get rapid feedback on her work. Despite the lack of formal review, the presentation helped generate discussion. She planned to revise her work for a peer-reviewed journal later, integrating the input from the conference.
• For the company's internal newsletter, articles were often submitted directly without peer review, meaning they were non-refereed. While these pieces served the purpose of communicating updates internally, they were not viewed with the same expectation of accuracy or scrutiny as the company's public reports.
• When researching a particular disease for a high school project, the student was advised to distinguish between non-refereed articles, from popular blogs, and refereed articles, from medical journals. The teacher stressed how peer review ensures that the information presented is scrutinized.
• While the book provided a good overview of the subject, the author acknowledged that the manuscript was published without being peer-reviewed, classifying it as non-refereed. This meant the reader must carefully assess the information, as the claims had not been independently verified by experts.